Cuda, STOP!
You're logic and reasoning is starting to make me waiver.
I'm fairly certain this is going to be the one illogical purchase I make (other than the electric pet rock I bought in the 80's...don't ask), I want the best power plant they offer and the SRT track day.
But all of those bullets you make really resonate. I will wait 'til July 09 and see if the 5.7's pushing 380, that is something to consider, a little clandestine 3rd party upgrade to push it over the top (and easily removable if warranty work is required), that starts to look really attractive!
I think you're right about the Charger rebate not happening w/ the Chally. The reason they have this is it reflects their old model of produce tons and then try to sell. I think they are going to get closer inventory to demand model like Toyota and you won't see this push....also, you know the Challenger is creating mayhem for them from a standpoint of who, now, wants a performance four door when the coupe is en route?