I would, in this case, go with your emotions. You buy a car like a Challenger to satisfy the man-car connection that begins deep in your gut and makes you smile broadly as the rise and fall of pistons synchronize with your heartbeat. It's not about shaving 1/2 of a tenth of a second off the quarter mile and who can corner without knocking over that last orange cone. Both cars are made to perform with power and handling.

The style and stance of the Challenger unapologetically speaks to the masculine within us. The GT-R looks like they hid another car under the hood. When I look at it the first thing that comes to mind is confusion.

My 2 cents.