Personally I would go for the Challenger. I had my fair share of Dodges in the past and not so fr past and although Dodge and Plymouth were sisteers under the skin, I feel that Dodge had the better styling. It wasnt as flashy and mod as Plymouth as it was more lean and angular which to me meant speed and power a bit more than flashy colors, scoops etc. But, to each their own and with the Challenger as the only one left (?) we have enough accessories to make them unique to our tastes.