Challenger wins in the looks dept...hands down it's the best retro of the group. (The Mustang then Camaro coming in second and third.) Reguarding the testing of cars...most, if not all tests during the performance years were...lets just say not always on the up and up. There were many ringers (cars that were "super tuned" from the factory) and so many of the numbers turned in by the test cars need to be taken with a grain of salt. With today's cars...if the test was not done with all the cars in the same place at the same time...the test tells you very little. Heads up is the only true test....
(It's still fun to read the old stories and road tests)