I don't see why this is listed with the "thumbsdown" logo. Seems like a fairly realistic portrayal of the R/T. They acknowledge strengths aplenty, and wish the handling was tighter. Even the much maligned interior is compared favorably to a Camaro.
I think this quote sums up the verdict from AW:
"It looks sweet, sounds great, lights the tires--everything you would want. I just want better handling to match."
Which seems pretty much par for the course compared to most reviews of the R/T. They didn't get completely carried away singing it's praises, but part of their job is to point out both strengths and weaknesses.