I think it was a fair result. The Mustang does the most with the least, and they'd be crucified for not picking it first. The Camaro made a big splash, but it seems like once people got used to it's styling, the enthusiasm cooled off a little bit. The Challenger is behind by the numbers, but its advantages in style, comfort and character merit the 2nd place ranking. In a contest of speed per dollar it still loses, but more of the testers said they'd want to own it compared to the Camaro.